Understanding Abnormal Returns: How to Calculate and Interpret Excess Returns in Finance

What Are Abnormal Returns?

Abnormal returns are essentially the unexpected part of an investment’s return that cannot be explained by general market movements or the investment’s inherent risk. They can be either positive (outperformance) or negative (underperformance). For instance, if a stock returns 15% in a year when the market only returned 10%, the 5% excess return is considered an abnormal return.
Abnormal returns are vital for evaluating investment strategies and assessing portfolio performance. They help investors understand whether their investments are generating returns beyond what would be expected given the level of risk taken. This information can be used to adjust investment strategies, evaluate fund managers, or identify market inefficiencies.

Calculation of Abnormal Returns

The calculation of abnormal returns involves subtracting the expected return from the actual return of an investment. The basic formula is:
[ \text{Abnormal Return} = \text{Actual Return} – \text{Expected Return} ]
To determine the actual return, you simply look at the total return of the investment over a specified period. The expected return, however, requires a bit more work.
One common method for estimating expected returns is using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM). The CAPM formula is:
[ Er = Rf + \beta (Rm – Rf) ]
Here, ( Er ) is the expected return, ( Rf ) is the risk-free rate, ( \beta ) is the beta of the asset (a measure of its volatility relative to the market), and ( Rm ) is the expected market return.
For example, if you have a stock with a beta of 1.2, a risk-free rate of 2%, and an expected market return of 8%, the expected return would be:
[ Er = 0.02 + 1.2(0.08 – 0.02) = 0.02 + 1.2(0.06) = 0.02 + 0.072 = 0.092 ]
If the actual return of this stock was 10%, then the abnormal return would be:
[ \text{Abnormal Return} = 0.10 – 0.092 = 0.008 ]

Expected Return Models

Besides CAPM, there are other models used to estimate expected returns. The Fama-French Three-Factor Model adds two additional factors to CAPM: size and value factors. This model helps account for differences in returns due to company size and value characteristics.
Another simpler approach is using historical averages. Here, you estimate the expected return based on the average historical returns of similar investments or the broader market.
Each model has its strengths and weaknesses, and choosing the right one depends on the specific context and data available.

Interpretation of Abnormal Returns

Interpreting abnormal returns involves understanding what they signify about investment performance. A positive abnormal return indicates that an investment has outperformed its expected return, suggesting good investment decisions or market inefficiencies that were exploited. Conversely, a negative abnormal return indicates underperformance.
Consistent positive abnormal returns might suggest that an investment strategy is effective or that there are persistent market inefficiencies being exploited. On the other hand, consistent negative abnormal returns could indicate poor strategy execution or higher-than-expected risk.
Abnormal returns also reflect the effectiveness of risk management strategies. If an investment consistently shows low volatility relative to its expected return, it may indicate good risk management practices.

Applications of Abnormal Returns

Abnormal returns have several practical applications in finance. They are crucial for performance evaluation of investments and portfolios. By analyzing abnormal returns over time, investors can assess whether their investment strategies are working as intended.
In event studies, abnormal returns help analyze the impact of specific events like earnings announcements or mergers on stock prices. For instance, if a company announces better-than-expected earnings and its stock price jumps significantly above what would be expected based on market conditions, this would result in a positive abnormal return.
Abnormal returns also aid in risk assessment by helping investors understand how much risk they are taking relative to the returns they are getting. This insight is essential for maintaining an optimal risk-return balance in portfolios.

Cumulative Abnormal Returns (CAR)

Cumulative Abnormal Returns (CAR) are calculated by summing individual abnormal returns over a specified period. CAR is particularly useful in assessing the impact of specific events on stock prices over a short window of time.
For example, if you want to see how a stock performed around an earnings announcement over three days, you would calculate the abnormal return for each day and then sum them up to get the CAR.
[ \text{CAR} = \sum{i=1}^{n} \text{Abnormal Return}i ]
This metric provides a clear picture of how an event affected the stock’s performance relative to market expectations.

Source: https://magnacumlaude.store
Category: Blog